Gettysburg: What If the South Had Won?


“The Democrats believed that Lincoln and the Republicans were a collection of radicals who were as much to blame as secessionists themselves,” Guelzo said. “They believed the Republicans were radical abolitionists, and what we need to do is get the moderate people together.”

Ten days after the battle of Gettysburg, which lasted from July 1 to July 3, 1863, the North began drafting young men, leading to the “draft riots” in New York, Boston and smaller cities like Toledo. Had Meade lost at Gettysburg and Lee began a military campaign in Pennsylvania and “you can imagine the political fallout in the coming weeks, and it’s not going to be good for the Union.”

As with all “what-if” games of history, not all historians agree with Guelzo’s scenarios.

PHOTOS: Top 10 Civil War Innovations

“In the long term, the north had a winning strategy,” said Elizabeth Varon, professor of history at the University of Virginia. “They had the numbers and the resources.”

Varon notes that while Meade was ousted after Gettysburg, Gen. Ulysses S. Grant, was winning victories in the western part of the country, such as Vicksburg.

“The superior of leadership of Lincoln as president, and superior generalship and command harmony of Lincoln and his team in spring of 1864 was decisive,” Varon said. “People raise the issue of Southern morale, and it would have been good (with a victory), but the once the Union had a team of generals who worked well with Lincoln and put advantages to bear, you were going to have a Union victory.”

Meade’s victory -- at a cost of 45,000 to 50,000 killed, wounded or missing on both sides -- sent Lee back home.

“The war in 1864 is being fought in Virginia,” said Ian Isherwood, assistant director of the Civil War Institute in Gettysburg, Pa. “That means the south is defending its soil. That’s a major difference.”

As for the battle itself, many historians look back at the famous “Pickett’s Charge” in which 12,500 units under Confederate General George Pickett attacked 3,500 Union forces on Cemetery Ridge. The Union held and the disastrous engagement on July 3 has since been referred to as the high water mark of the Confederacy. But Guelzo said the charge wasn’t the only moment that could have tipped the battle, the war, and possibly American history, the other way.

“There were a dozen times where the difference of 15 minutes, or a junior officer’s decision might have meant difference between victory and defeat,” said Guelzo, who lives on part of the battlefield. “It’s not a static affair. It’s playing multiple rounds of Russian roulette.”

Recommended for you