UN Court Orders Japan to End Antarctic Whale Hunt


The UN's top court on Monday ordered Japan to end its annual Antarctic whale hunt, saying in a landmark ruling that the program was a commercial activity disguised as science.

"Japan shall revoke any existant authorization, permit or license granted in relation to JARPA II (research program) and refrain from granting any further permits," said the International Court of Justice's Judge Peter Tomka.

Agreeing with Australia, which in 2010 hauled Japan before the Hague-based ICJ in a bid to end whale hunting in the Southern Ocean, Tomka said that "special permissions granted by Japan are not for purposes of scientific research."

Photos: Mammals of the Sea

It may not sound very appealing, but whale vomit is actually quite valuable.
Photo courtesy Flickr | Peter Kaminski

"The evidence does not establish that the program's design and implementation are reasonable in relation to its stated (scientific) objectives," Tomka said.

While Norway and Iceland have commercial whaling programs in spite of a 1986 International Whaling Commission (IWC) moratorium, Japan insisted its program was scientific, while admitting that the resulting meat ended up on plates back home.

Tokyo was accused of exploiting a legal loophole in the 1986 ban on commercial whaling that allowed the practice to collect scientific data.

Conservation groups voiced happiness at the ruling, which Japan said it would respect despite "deep disappointment".

"As a state that respects the rule of law… and as a responsible member of the global community, Japan will abide by the decision of the court," chief negotiator Koji Tsuruoka told reporters outside the United Nations' top court.

Australia's lawyer Bill Campbell said he welcomed the decision and repeated his hope that it would not affect relations between the two countries.

"The decision of the court today, important as it is, has given us the opportunity to draw a line under the legal dispute and move on," Campbell said.

Australia said that since 1988 Japan has slaughtered more than 10,000 whales under the program, putting the Asian nation in breach of international conventions and its obligation to preserve marine mammals and their environment.

Pete Bethune, a former activist with militant conservation group Sea Shepherd who spent five months in a Japanese prison for his protests, broke down after the verdict.

"Today is a great day for justice," he told journalists at the court.

"This decision sends a clear message to governments around the world that the exploitation of animals will no longer be tolerated and animals must be protected at the highest level," said Claire Bass, head of wildlife campaigns at the World Society for the Protection of Animals.

"All eyes are now on Japan to respect this decision," she said.

Recommended for you